Tuesday, October 8, 2024

The Curse or Karna


The Curse or Karna


This blog is the part of thinking activity of the paper no 201 The Pre-Independence Literature unit 2. The Brahmin's Curse, also known as The Curse or Karna, is a play by T.P. Kailasam that retells the story of Karna from the Mahabharata. The play explores themes of fate, destiny, caste discrimination, and the struggles of the subaltern.  

Interpret all the acts and scenes in brief.




Act 1, Scene 1

Raama, Karna's teacher, gives Karna a powerful weapon called the "Bhaargava" astra. Raama tells Karna to use the weapon wisely and only against bad people. Karna practices with the weapon and does it very well.

Act 1, Scene 2

Karna is taking care of Raama when a wasp bites him. Karna doesn't cry out in pain. Raama finds out that Karna is really a Kshatriya, not a Brahmin. Raama gets angry and puts a curse on Karna. If Karna ever tells anyone he is a Kshatriya, he will lose his skills. Karna begs Raama to forgive him, and Raama does. But Raama knows that bad things will happen to Karna in the future.

Karna is a good person who wants to help others. He is very skilled with weapons and will use his skills to fight bad guys. However, the curse from Raama will make his life difficult.


Act 2, Scene 1



Karna, a great archer, comes to the Royal Stadium and challenges Arjuna, who is known as the best archer. Karna shows off his skills by shooting an arrow through many leaves on a tree. Suyodhana, the Crowned Prince, welcomes Karna and wants him to fight Arjuna. After a lot of arguing, Karna wants to fight Arjuna's teachers, but it's too dark, so they have to wait. 


Suyodhana makes Karna the King of Angaland. Gaandhaara tells Karna to shoot an arrow at Arjuna to show his thanks. Karna doesn't want to, but Bheemasena makes fun of him and calls him low-born. Karna can't shoot because of a curse.


Act 3, Scene 1



In the Royal Palace, there is a competition to find a husband for the princess. The challenge is to shoot an arrow at a target while only looking at its shadow. Many kings and princes have tried but failed. Draupada, the King of Paanchaala, encourages everyone to keep trying. Gaandhaara thinks the princess is not a good prize.

Anga, who doesn't seem important, steps forward. He makes a bow from a steel bar, puts a string on it, and gets ready to shoot. But then everyone finds out that Anga is from a low-born family and was made a king by Suyodhana. The princess is surprised and doesn't want to marry him. Anga tries to shoot the arrow but misses, and the show ends.

Act 3, Scene 2



Anga, feeling bad after he failed, is stopped by the King of Kuruland. The King asks Anga why he ran away and left his bow and arrow. Anga says that the princess's mean words made him do it. He also says that he is cursed by his teacher, Raama, and when he is reminded of his low birth, he becomes ashamed and can't do anything. Anga asks his king to forgive him and says he is alone and has no friends. The King feels sorry for Anga and takes him away.

Act 4, Scene 1

In the throne room, Gaandhaara thinks the Princess Paanchaalee deserves the bad things that happened to her because she was rude. Vidura tells Suyodhana, the King, to do his job and not forget his responsibilities. Dhritaraashtra says that kings can't do anything wrong. 


Bheeshma tells Suyodhana that a good name is important and that he should not let his power and wealth make him forget who he is. Yuyutsu, the youngest of the Royal Brothers, stands up and tries to talk, but others push him back. He is angry that his brothers are not helping him and blames the King for involving his Royal Sister in the problem. 


The King lets Yuyutsu speak and asks him what is wrong. Yuyutsu says that a person's life is good if people remember their name. He hopes to help in the discussion. The King tells Yuyutsu not to talk too long or flatter him too much. Yuyutsu says he wants the King to follow the wisdom of their ancestors. Dhritaraashtra says that kings can't do anything wrong and that the blame is on Brahmin counselors. 



Bheeshma tells Suyodhana to be a good person and do his job. There is a fight among the Dhaartaraashtra Princes. Yuyutsu stands up and tries to talk, but others push him back. The King lets Yuyutsu speak. Yuyutsu wants the King to listen to the wisdom of their ancestors. The King talks about the family history of the Kuru House and how Bheeshma is the true leader. 


The King says he doesn't trust anyone in the assembly for advice. He talks about the problems his family members have and says he will rule with love and cherish those who love and cherish him. Finally, the King decides what will happen to the Pandava Cousins and their wife. He says that Princess Paanchaalee should be placed among the chambermaids and assigns the Crown Prince Dussaasanah to take care of her. The King of Angaland gets angry and threatens Dussaasanah.

Act 4, Scene 2



In this scene, Paanchaalee (Draupadi), Bheema, and Anga are talking about what happened to Draupadi in the court. Draupadi was humiliated and feels very sad. She goes through many emotions and finally realizes the purpose of her birth. Bheema is angry at Anga for not protecting Draupadi. Anga says that he was cursed and couldn't do anything. Bheema carries Anga away because he is sad.


Act 5, Scene 1



Anga, the Field Marshal, is worried about the war. The king, Dhritarashtra, is also worried and asks Anga for advice. Anga tells him to focus on the battle and not worry about right or wrong. The king trusts Anga and asks for his opinion. Anga says he is loyal and ready for battle. After the king leaves, Anga and Sumantra talk about preparations for the next day and then go to sleep. An old woman, Queen Kuntee, enters Anga's tent. She is mysterious and silent. Anga wonders why she is there at such a late hour.




Anga is shocked to find out that he is the brother of Dharma, Bheema, and Arjuna, the sons of Queen Kuntee. He is confused about whether to spare his newfound brother or fight for his Emperor. He talks to the deified arrow on the wall, symbolizing his loyalty to the Emperor. He is torn between his loyalty to the Emperor and his newfound family ties. Raadhā, an elderly woman, enters. She is Anga's mother, and he seeks comfort and guidance from her.

Act 5, Scene 2



Anga and Maadra are on the battlefield. Maadra is impatient and wants Anga to start the real battle. Anga realizes the seriousness of the situation and acknowledges that he had been focused on showing his skills rather than his duty to the Emperor. Maadra advises Anga to aim at Arjuna's chest, not higher, to kill him. However, when Anga prepares to shoot his arrow, he remembers what happened earlier. He had been tricked by Krishna's cleverness, which saved Arjuna's life. Anga is frustrated and decides not to use his serpent shaft again. 


Maadra is confused by Anga's behavior and worries about his mental state. Anga mentions "Raama" (referring to Parashurama), claiming that he will destroy the enemy with a blade of grass. Maadra thinks Anga has lost his mind and wants to get help for him. Anga is determined to use a blade of grass to end the war. He believes that this unusual method will achieve his goal, even though Maadra thinks Anga has become mentally unstable. The scene shows Anga's mental turmoil and his growing disillusionment with the war. His decision to use a blade of grass as a weapon signifies his desperation to put an end to the senseless bloodshed.


Maadra realizes that Anga is mentally unwell. He reflects on his own role and the absurdity of his situation. Maadra tries to help Anga, but Anga reveals that he is cursed and can't move when he is reminded of his low birth. Maadra is shocked and tries to help Anga, but fails. He decides to take Anga back for rest. 


In Arjuna's chariot, Krishna urges Arjuna to wake up and continue the battle. Krishna encourages Arjuna to use his Shiva shaft to end the battle. Arjuna is torn between his reluctance to kill an unarmed foe and the fear of his brother's defeat. Arjuna decides to put aside his reservations and aims his bow at Anga, tears welling up in his eyes as he prepares to strike.



Arjuna shoots an arrow that hits Anga in the chest. Maadra and Aswattha are angry and sad. Aswattha curses Arjuna and the entire Pandava lineage. Anga dies, and his last moments are filled with regret for the curses that seem to follow him throughout his life. The scene ends with Aswattha and Maadra grieving the loss of their friend Anga.

{I used AI chatboat to interpret the acts}

Karna - The voice of Subaltern





The Brahmin's Curse is built on Karna's intention to prove his worth to the world, and Kailasam's purpose of questioning the treatment given to Karna.n Kailasam's play The Brahmin's Curse there is Raadha who assumes such a role for Karna.

Karna is afflicted not by the Brahmin’s curse, but by that which is the cause of that curse–the irregularity of his origin. The sins of the parents are visited upon the children. He is the victim of society’s will to live. Society cast him out. Having received no kindness from society he owes it no obligations. The victim of society turns out to be the enemy of society. His obligations are purely personal, and Karna becomes the nemesis of the Pandavas.


In this play, Karna represents a subaltern character - someone from a marginalized or lower social group who lacks power in society. Despite his extraordinary skills in archery, Karna faces constant discrimination and obstacles because of his low birth as a "sootha" (a lower caste).


The concept of the subaltern is clearly illustrated through several key aspects of Karna's experience:


#Social Exclusion: 

Karna is initially denied the opportunity to compete in the tournament due to his low birth. This shows how subaltern individuals are often excluded from participating in important social events or institutions.The word "Poor" appears 36 times in the play. 

"You are faultless as a pupil, Karna; but you

make a poor, poor liar! "


"I fear I’m poor of courtly talk.

I'am only after chance to face one Paartha, "


It suggests a rejection of elite culture and its associated conventions, a desire for authenticity and genuine connection, an assertion of individuality, and a subtle critique of the courtly culture. The speaker's discomfort with formal language and their yearning for a genuine encounter with a figure like Paartha highlight their subaltern perspective, challenging the dominant norms and values of the ruling class


"POOR HELPLESS ANGA. Unarm’d....helpless . poor....poor ."

The repetition of "poor" and "helpless" emphasizes ANGA's dire situation


#Identity Struggle:

Karna struggles with his identity throughout the play. He initially hides his true caste to learn archery from Raama, showing how subaltern individuals sometimes feel compelled to conceal their background to access opportunities.


# Patronage and Elevation:

When Crown Prince Suyodhana recognizes Karna's skills and makes him King of Angaland, it demonstrates how subaltern figures often need support from those in power to gain social standing. However, this elevation doesn't fully erase the stigma of Karna's birth.


# Internalized Oppression:

Raama's curse, which paralyzes Karna whenever he thinks of his low birth, symbolizes how societal prejudices can become internalized by subaltern individuals, hindering their ability to act even when given the opportunity.

The word "Brahmin's Curse appeares 12 times in the play. 

"With lie of

brahmin birth hast thou acquir’d the mastery

of arms second not e’en to me! And for thy

dastard lie, list to a Brahmin’s CURSE:


IF EVER YOU SHOULD HENCEFORTH

SORELY NEED THE USE OF ARMS

YOU’VE LEARNT OF ME.......THE BAREST

TALK, THE MEREST THOUGHT OF THY

SUPPOSED SOOTHA BIRTH CROSSING THY

MIND...WILL SWELL THY HEART TO

SENSE OF SHAME, WILL DULL THINE

EYES AND MIND, NUMB AND PARALYSE

THY LIMBS BEYOND THEIR PO’WR_ TO

HELE. THER. MAKEN THES SLIGHTEST,

SMALLEST USE OF KNOWLEDGE THAT

YOU’VE LEARNT OF ME! AVAUNT!

AVAUNT!, ERE I INFLICT A FURTHER

CURSE ON THEE! "


The quote reflects the hierarchical caste system in India, where Brahmins were considered the highest caste and untouchables (like Karna) were at the lowest. The Brahmin's curse highlights the power dynamics and social discrimination faced by untouchables.

If we do breakdown of the quote from a subaltern perspective:


Reinforcement of Caste Hierarchy: The Brahmin's curse reinforces the notion that caste is a fixed and immutable characteristic that determines one's fate. By threatening to strip Karna of his martial skills, the Brahmin asserts the superiority of his caste and the inferiority of Karna's.

Denial of Agency: The curse suggests that Karna's achievements are not solely due to his own efforts but rather are a result of the Brahmin's blessings. This denies Karna agency and reinforces the idea that his success is dependent on the favor of the upper caste.

Psychological Manipulation: The curse is designed to instill fear and self-doubt in Karna. By threatening to strip him of his skills, the Brahmin seeks to control Karna and prevent him from challenging his authority.

Subaltern Resistance: While the curse is a powerful tool of oppression, it also highlights the resilience of the subaltern. Karna's continued pursuit of his goals despite the Brahmin's curse is a form of resistance against the caste system.

The quote reflects the power dynamics and social discrimination faced by subaltern groups in India. It highlights the ways in which the dominant caste can use their privilege to oppress and control those below them. However, it also suggests the possibility of subaltern resistance and the potential for individuals to overcome the limitations imposed by their caste.


"A helpless victim of A BRAHMIN’S CURSE !A BRAHMIN’S FATAL

[CURSE ! A BRAHMIN’S POTENT CURSE ! TAINTED BLOOD!

AND LEST MY BRAHMIN’S WEAKLY

[BLOOD

DO TURN ME CRAVEN TO MY VOw,

TILL I FULFIL MY VENGING VOW

I THUS RENOUNCE MY BRAHMINHOOD!"


Brahmins were considered the highest caste and were believed to have special powers and privileges. The curse placed on the character suggests that even someone born into a lower caste can be affected by the power of a Brahmin's curse.

The phrase "tainted blood" refers to the belief that one's caste is determined by their birth and is an inherent part of their identity. This idea of "tainted blood" was used to justify discrimination against lower-caste groups, such as the untouchables.

Overall, the lines emphasize the power dynamics and social discrimination faced by lower-caste groups in India. They suggest that even individuals who are born into a lower caste can be subject to the oppression and control of the upper caste.


The lines "Whensoe’er my lowly birth is flung at me, And made to cross my mind, my brain refuses thought!" reflect the character's determination to overcome the limitations imposed by their caste. Despite facing constant reminders of their lower-caste status, the character refuses to allow these thoughts to affect their self-esteem or their goals. This demonstrates their resilience and their ability to rise above the challenges faced by their caste.


# Silencing of Voice:

In the final confrontation with Bheemasena, Karna is unable to respond to insults about his birth due to the curse. This represents how subaltern voices are often silenced or rendered ineffective in society.


# Talent vs. Birth:

The play consistently juxtaposes Karna's exceptional skills with the limitations imposed by his birth, critiquing a society that values inherited status over individual merit.

The word lowborn is used 11 times in the play.

"Thee low-born churl! And you believe

You’re lowly born? Nay, nay, you're not!:

You’te not a sootha, nor a Kshairiya,

Nor a brahmana like all these vermin doom’d

To die! MINE EYES THAT NOW ARE

(OPED TO SEE

BEYOND A HUMAN’S FLESH-BOUND

SIGHT "

# Psychological Impact:

Karna's distress at the end of the play, when he laments his condition to Gaandhaara, highlights the psychological toll that constant discrimination and marginalization can have on subaltern individuals.


Through Karna's character, the play offers a critique of rigid social hierarchies and explores how talented individuals from lower castes struggle to find their place in a society that consistently undermines their worth based on birth. It illustrates how even when subaltern figures achieve nominal positions of power, they often remain constrained by deeply ingrained societal prejudices and their own internalized sense of inferiority.


In this excerpt, Satyavati is portrayed as a woman of low social status, born into the Sudra caste. This is emphasized by the phrase "lowly soodra caste." The contrast between her humble origins and her eventual position as a queen highlights the power dynamics and social mobility within the kingdom.


Despite her low birth, Satyavati is described as a woman of great value and worth. The line "That we all vaunt and flaunt" suggests that she is admired and respected by many, even those from higher castes. This suggests that her character and qualities have transcended her social status, making her a figure of admiration and respect.

Words : 1768

Image: 12

Video: 2

References : 


Full Text of “the Curse or Karna.” archive.org/stream/unset0000unse_h8e3/unset0000unse_h8e3_djvu.txt.

www.wisdomlib.org. The English Plays and Poems of Kailasam. 17 Mar. 2022, www.wisdomlib.org/history/compilation/triveni-journal/d/doc68524.html.

No comments:

Post a Comment

New Trends in Literature and AI-Driven Transformations in Language Studies-Seminar

 Greetings everyone! On 21 September 2024, I participated in a virtual seminar on "New Trends in Literature and AI-Driven Transformatio...